Economics • Market Failure

Externalities & Interventions

Market equilibrium and welfare

0 20 40 60 80 100 0 20 40 60 80 100 Quantity Price ($) Pm Qm MPB (D) MPC (S1)
  • CS Consumer surplus
  • PS Producer surplus
  • Gov Tax revenue / subsidy cost
  • DWL Welfare loss

Examples

Externality

Choose Negative or Positive in the title bar to add one.

Government intervention

Choose Tax or Subsidy in the title bar to intervene.

The market

Economic indicators

Price paid by consumers (Pc) Consumer $0
Price received by producers (Pp) Producer $0
Market quantity (Qm) Output 0
Consumer surplus (CS) Welfare $0
Producer surplus (PS) Welfare $0
Welfare loss (DWL) Efficiency $0

Externalities & Interventions — Explanation

An externality is a cost or benefit that falls on a third party: someone who isn't the buyer or the seller. A free market only weighs private costs and benefits: supply is marginal private cost (MPC) and demand is marginal private benefit (MPB). So it settles at the market quantity Qm, where MPB = MPC, and ignores the external part.

The best quantity for society, the social optimum Qs, is where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost (MSB = MSC). Choose an externality in the title bar:

The red welfare loss (deadweight loss) is the triangle between MSB and MSC, from Qm to Qs: the units society values at less than they cost, or the units it would value at more than they cost but doesn't get.

Correcting it. Choose Tax or Subsidy in the title bar. A specific tax equal to the external cost per unit (a Pigouvian tax) moves supply up by exactly the gap, so the market produces Qs and the welfare loss disappears. A subsidy equal to the external benefit does the same for a positive externality. Set a tax or subsidy too high and the welfare loss comes back, on the other side.

Tick Show welfare areas to shade consumer surplus, producer surplus, the government's tax revenue or subsidy spending, and the welfare loss. The examples animate each case from the free market. The elasticity sliders tilt the curves: a flatter curve is more price elastic.

Cambridge International AS & A Level Economics (9708): market failure, externalities, and government intervention through indirect taxes and subsidies.

Where this fits

  • AP: AP Microeconomics
  • AQA: AQA A Level Economics (7136)
  • Cambridge: Cambridge IGCSE Economics (0455); Cambridge A Level Economics (9708) Goes beyond Cambridge IGCSE Economics (0455): 0455 says market-failure diagrams aren't required: the MSB/MSC diagram, welfare loss and Pigouvian tax go beyond it.
  • IB: IB Economics HL; IB Economics SL
  • NCEA Level 2 Economics: 91228 Analyse a contemporary economic issue of special interest using economic concepts and models
  • NCEA Level 3 Economics: 91402 Demonstrate understanding of government interventions where the market fails to deliver efficient or equitable outcomes
  • Pearson Edexcel International: Edexcel International GCSE Economics (4EC1); Edexcel International A Level Economics Goes beyond Edexcel International GCSE Economics (4EC1): 4EC1 has no externality diagrams: MSB/MSC, the welfare loss triangle and Pigouvian tax go beyond it.
  • USDP: USDP Economics Goes beyond USDP Economics: MSB/MSC diagrams and the welfare loss go beyond a typical high-school course.

Externalities & Interventions — Key Terms

Key concepts in English, with te reo Māori, Chinese (Simplified) and Korean.

EnglishTe reo Māori中文(简体)한국어What it means on this page
Externalityno attested term外部性 (wàibùxìng)외부효과 (oebu hyogwa)A cost or benefit affecting a third party who did not choose to be involved in the transaction that caused it.
Negative Externalityno attested term负外部性 (fù wàibùxìng)부정적 외부효과 (bujeongjeok oebu hyogwa)A cost imposed on a third party, such as pollution, that is not reflected in the market price.
Positive Externalityno attested term正外部性 (zhèng wàibùxìng)긍정적 외부효과 (geungjeongjeok oebu hyogwa)A benefit received by a third party, such as from education or vaccination, that is not reflected in the market price.
Marginal Private Cost (MPC)no attested term边际私人成本 (biānjì sīrén chéngběn)한계사적비용 (hangye sajeok biyong)The cost to the producer of making one more unit of a good, ignoring any cost imposed on others.
Marginal Social Cost (MSC)no attested term边际社会成本 (biānjì shèhuì chéngběn)한계사회적비용 (hangye sahoejeok biyong)The full cost to society of one more unit of a good: marginal private cost plus any external cost.
Marginal Private Benefit (MPB)no attested term边际私人收益 (biānjì sīrén shōuyì)한계사적편익 (hangye sajeok pyeonik)The benefit to the consumer of using one more unit of a good, ignoring any benefit gained by others.
Marginal Social Benefit (MSB)no attested term边际社会收益 (biānjì shèhuì shōuyì)한계사회적편익 (hangye sahoejeok pyeonik)The full benefit to society of one more unit of a good: marginal private benefit plus any external benefit.
Social Optimumno attested term社会最优 (shèhuì zuìyōu)사회적 최적 (sahoejeok choejeok)The quantity at which marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost (MSB = MSC): the best level of output for society as a whole, once external costs and benefits are counted.
Market Failureno attested term市场失灵 (shìchǎng shīlíng)시장실패 (sijang silpae)A situation where the free market allocates resources inefficiently, producing too much or too little of a good.
Deadweight Welfare Lossno attested term福利无谓损失 (fúlì wúwèi sǔnshī)사회후생 손실 (sahoe husaeng sonsil)The loss of total economic welfare that occurs when the market produces at a quantity other than the socially optimal level.
Pigouvian Taxno attested term庇古税 (Bìgǔ shuì)피구세 (piguse)A tax set equal to the external cost of a negative externality, intended to bring private and social cost into line.
Indirect Taxno attested term间接税 (jiànjiē shuì)간접세 (ganjeobse)A tax on spending, collected from the seller. Here, a tax on each unit sold shifts supply up from S1 to S2; set equal to the external cost, it is a Pigouvian tax.
Specific Taxno attested term从量税 (cóngliàng shuì)종량세 (jongnyangse)An indirect tax of a fixed amount on each unit sold, such as $2 a litre. It shifts the supply curve up by the same amount at every quantity, so S2 is parallel to S1.
Ad Valorem Taxno attested term从价税 (cóngjià shuì)종가세 (jonggase)An indirect tax charged as a percentage of the price, such as GST. It pivots the supply curve upwards, so the tax per unit grows as the price rises.
Subsidypūtea āwhina补贴 (bǔtiē)보조금 (bojogeum)A payment by government to a producer or consumer, used here to encourage the output of goods with positive externalities.
Consumer Surplusno attested term消费者剩余 (xiāofèizhě shèngyú)소비자잉여 (sobija ingyeo)The difference between what consumers are willing to pay for a good and what they actually pay.
Producer Surplusno attested term生产者剩余 (shēngchǎnzhě shèngyú)생산자잉여 (saengsanja ingyeo)The difference between the price producers receive for a good and the minimum price they would be willing to accept.

On the te reo Māori column. Terms marked as gaps have no attested equivalent in the sources checked — Karaitiana Taiuru's Dictionary of Māori Computer and Social Media Terms, Paekupu, the Reserve Bank's te reo financial glossary, NZQA and Te Aka. No coinage is printed as though it were established; where a class needs one, commission it from Te Taura Whiri i te Reo Māori and credit the translator. Te reo Māori is not italicised and takes no plural "s".